Indiana’s Most Sinister Stories

True crime podcast episodes based on Indiana cases

While Indiana might be seen as a flyover state, it has its own share of grim history. Notably, figures like Charles Manson, Jim Jones, and H.H. Holmes all have ties to the land of Hoosiers, adding a darker layer to its narrative. By the way, did you know the average person crosses paths with a murderer about 36 times in their life? Or that more than half of murder victims know their killers? Check out our podcast episodes that delve into cold cases, the macabre, even the devil himself —all right here in our own backyard.

Spook Street

The murder of 16-year-old Sylvia Likens in 1965 ranks among Indiana's most gruesome crimes. For three months, she was brutally tortured by her own caretaker before her tragic death. This harrowing case continues to haunt the state’s history.

Infamous Indy

This podcast, as you might expect, is based in Indianapolis and focuses on Indiana-based true crime stories. Notable cases featured include the Delphi Murders, Herb Baumeister, the Hollandsburg Massacre, and the murder of Shannon Hall in Carmel. If you’re interested in the darker side of Indiana's history, this is a must-listen!

Cold Case Chronicles

This podcast has its roots in Indiana and dives into chilling cases like "Little Linda Weldy," the 1986 murder of Brandie Peltz, who was discovered dead in her bathtub, and the brutal attack on a mother in Argos while her children were present. It's a gripping exploration of some of the state’s most unsettling stories.

My Favorite Murder With Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

One of the more unique true crime podcasts I’ve come across offers a comedic twist, aiming to find the silver lining in the cases they discuss. You can find episodes covering the 2012 Richmond Hill Explosion, the murder of heiress Marjorie Jackson in 1970, and various other cases from across the U.S., including a spotlight on Kentucky. It's a refreshing take on the genre that blends humor with serious topics!

Get our free mobile app

Paranormal Podcast Episodes

Indiana is home to the infamous Demon House in Gary, made famous by eerie photos and its feature on Ghost Adventures. Zac Baggins and his crew from the Travel Channel and Discovery+ created a feature-length documentary about the house in 2018.

The state also boasts numerous cryptid sightings, including UFO encounters, Bigfoot, and even a case of cursed stairs. Here are some podcast episodes that delve into these otherworldly stories!

READ MORE: Murder, Mystery, and The Occult: Podcasts About Kentucky's Dark Side